It's not the easiest question to answer. For me, it definitely depends on the circumstances. I LOVE surprises on Christmas. Unlike many moms, I never let my kids know what their gifts are ahead of time. If I think they even suspect, I get them something else. Christmas is about surprises. But what about surprise parties? Like for birthdays?
That's very different. I don't think anyone has ever thrown me a surprise birthday party, and let me be clear: That is just fine. The last thing I'd want is to arrive somewhere to find a bunch of my friends, when I didn't know they were coming. I mean just imagine me in my "sub-casual" look: pajama bottoms, sweatshirt, stringy hair, no makeup. Now imagine this "me" walking into a surprise birthday party with a bunch of people. Terrifying, I tell you.
As surprise parties go, you really need to know the person well and understand his or her level of comfort with being blindsided. For that reason, I've thrown surprise birthday parties for only two of my kids: Shulamith and Eli. Luke and Isaiah would never want a surprise party. They don't even like un-surprise parties, particularly. Isaiah humors me and lets me bake him a cake on his birthday, gather the family, give him a present, and sing; but given the choice, I'm pretty sure he'd pass on even that much attention.
Oh my goodness! It just occurred to me that I have no idea how Seth would feel about a surprise party. Hmmm? My guess is he'd be okay with it? But it's not something he'd truly appreciate? I've never thrown him a surprise party, and he still loves me very much, so I guess that's okay.
When Shulamith turned 14, I threw her a surprise birthday party. I was 8 months' pregnant with Seth, but I managed to pull off a successful surprise that included a dozen teenage girls, and miraculously, Shulamith never found out about it. We all gathered at Red Robin in Burlington, WA, and the girls helped me decorate. Decorating is surely not my strength, so I was grateful they were there. (Hi, Tia! Hi, Lynnsey!) At the appointed time, my mom arrived with Shulamith. She walked in and noticed me first. "Mom? What are you doing here?" Then she looked up and saw all her friends seated around a big oblong table, just as they shouted "Surprise!" It was perfect. She opened so many nice gifts, and we all dined on burgers and fries, tons of ice cream, cake and candy. I think she was so happy.
Seven years later, as Eli approached age 14, I asked Shulamith if she thought he would like a similar event. "Oh, he definitely would. I loved mine!" This time around it was less formal, mostly because I didn't know his friends nearly as well as I knew Shulamith's. His best friend Jonah helped me know whom to invite, and a bunch of guys showed up at a pizza place in Billings, MT. I don't remember a lot about what happened after that, other than lots of pizza eating, soda drinking, and teenage boy humor. But I think Eli liked it.
Last weekend, in celebration of Eli's 29th birthday, Amanda threw him a yet another surprise party. She even managed to find decorations themed with classic horror film villains. Eli, possibly the gentlest, kindest soul I've ever known, is obsessed with horror flicks, the gorier the better. I took Eli out for some shaved ice custard, while Amanda decorated their house with scary pictures hanging from the ceiling, and everyone arrived. It was a small gathering, just our family plus Amanda's brother and his family, but they all hid with the lights low, and jumped out with a hearty "Surprise!" as we walked in the door. Another success! I don't think Eli had any idea. He got several fun presents: tickets to the upcoming Ice Nine Kills concert, Lego, Stance socks, and lots of good wishes, but he says the best present is this girl right here:
Happy birthday, Eli! We all love you so much.