Last Monday was Gerald's birthday. So what did we do? We all met at Taco Bell for lunch before Gerald headed to work. Okay, just so you know, we did have a birthday dinner, with cake, etc. the day before, but he kept telling us that wasn't his birthday, so we thought maybe he wanted some sort of recognition on Monday (his actual birthday) as well? Generally, he doesn't like his birthday to be celebrated at all, so that was a bit confusing, but what could we do? And why Taco Bell, you might ask. That's a long story. Suffice it to say that Mathew loves Taco Bell and thinks it's the absolute best place to celebrate birthdays, and Gerald and Seth both like it too, so that's where we went. But I issued this warning to all: Don't ever take
me to Taco Bell for
my birthday. Not ever.
As we ate our double-decker tacos (Isaiah, Seth, and Shulamith), bean burritos (Gerald), fresco-style chicken soft tacos (Am I
always dieting???), and cheesy gordita crunch with cheesy fiesta potatoes (Matt), somehow the conversation turned philosophical, particularly to the subject of parenting. I have no idea why this happened, but for some reason, Gerald and I found ourselves discussing our parenting beliefs, how they differ from most other parents', and why they are the best fit for us. That's the most important part: "for us." We would never try to force our beliefs on others or offer unsolicited advice; unless someone wants to know, we'll keep our opinions to ourselves. Through the years, though, people
have asked, some because they were seeking actual suggestions for parenting their own children and others just out of idle curiosity. In either case, I thought this might be a good forum in which to present our ideas, because reading here is totally voluntary. If you're not interested in parenting philosophies, feel free to skip this particular post. I will write something totally different next time. I promise!
Though we never discussed it before we got married (Bad idea! Couples
should discuss these things before they marry; we just didn't), both Gerald and I fell naturally into a philosophy I call "gentle" or "non-punitive" parenting. By that I mean our goal was to take a gentle approach and never to engage in any sort of punishing. We tried to be the "guides on the side," allowing our children, as soon as they were able, to decide most things for themselves, while providing lots of encouragement along the way. I remember hearing someone admonishing parents to "choose your battles" and thinking to myself, "but I don't want
any battles." Is that possible? Is it possible to simply get along with one's kids, without a lot of conflict and contention? We believe it is.
Our theory is this. When they're too young to understand danger, it's our job to keep them safe. When they're too young to understand the value of material things, it's our job to keep valuables out of reach. As they grow and mature both physically and cognitively, they become able to take on more and more responsibility for themselves and for their choices, and we let them. In most cases, we found that they knew far better than we what was best for them. Kids are smart. If you let them run their own lives, it just might surprise you what a great job they do.
We let them eat when they were hungry and sleep when they were tired. We didn't tell them what to eat, how to dress, how to style their hair, or when to go to bed. With regard to food, we offered a variety of nutritious choices along with plenty of treats, and we let them choose for themselves. Ultimately, we have two kids who will eat almost anything, two who are somewhat picky, and one who is the pickiest eater on the planet. I suspect this is exactly what we would have ended up with had we tried to legislate their eating; we just bypassed all the hassle. And encouraging them to choose their own clothing, dress themselves, and style their hair however they like? I can't see any possible downside to this.
Then there's the bedtime issue. That's the one people tend to be most shocked by, well along with no curfews for teenagers. The thing is kids' sleep needs vary greatly, just like those of adults. Three of our kids take after Gerald and barely need any sleep at all. This was true even when they were little. I remember Luke staying up until 10:00 or even 11:00 p.m. in early elementary school, and waking well rested and ready each morning without an alarm. It was the same with Eli, and it's the same with Seth. In contrast, Shulamith and Isaiah are like me; we need lots and lots of sleep. I sleep 9 - 10 hours daily. When Isaiah was in elementary school, he decided that he needed to be in bed by 9:00 sharp, no matter what. And he was. OCD like his mom, missing that self-imposed deadline by even a couple minutes made him anxious. I remember him telling me
in all seriousness that he would never be able to have children. Why not, I asked. "Because I could get a kid like Eli who stays up late, and I wouldn't be able to go to bed at 9:00."
So what about discipline? Don't all kids need discipline? It depends on how you use the word. As a noun, I love the word. It comes from the same root as "disciple," meaning to teach, to guide, to lead, and best of all, to serve! We tried to model self-discipline for our kids and to be good examples of positive behavior, and we hoped they would watch and follow. But used as a verb, the word "discipline" often means the same or close to the same as punishment. That is never a good idea. Even if it were effective, I wouldn't be a fan of the concept, but the truth is, it isn't. All punishment does is make people sneaky. They learn how to do exactly what they want to do without getting caught. They modify their behavior in the presence of the punisher, but once outside his presence, they tend to become all the more rebellious because they resent the whole situation. Punishment breeds resentment, and it teaches nothing. And that resentment can last a really long time. Ask any adult who was punished as a child by being forced to scrub floors to lift a finger to scrub a floor as an adult. No way! Floor scrubbing = punishment. Punishment = resentment. End of story.
As you might guess, we took a lot of flak for our methods, especially early on when are kids were very young. I remember one person telling me my children would never be able to function in school because we didn't discipline them at home. They would never sit still or follow directions because we didn't give them rules and consequences. If we didn't change our plan, by the time they reached middle and high school, they would probably be involved in drugs or in trouble with the law. Yes, someone actually said these things to me. But one by one, our kids entered the public school system, and one by one, they excelled. They were happy, well-adjusted students, who enjoyed school. They did their homework with no prodding from us. They made friends. Their teachers loved them. The older four continued through high school and graduated. We had not one single issue with a teacher or administrator.
Our two oldest kids attended private universities and graduated with honors. The oldest is working on his PhD. Our middle kid is half way through a computer science degree and works 30 hours a week to help us pay his tuition and expenses. Our fourth child successfully completed one semester of college and is now serving a full time mission for our church. I suppose the jury is still out on Seth since he's not yet a teenager, but I have no reason to believe he will be any different. I'm his mom so not at all objective, but he is really one of the nicest boys I know.
I should probably mention that Gerald always says we have "easy kids." He's right. They lived before they came to earth and brought with them their own unique personalities. And yes, they have been easy to raise. But I also believe that had we chosen to micromanage their lives and taken a punitive, authoritarian approach, they would have been a lot harder. In fact, I'm sure of it. Gentle, non-punitive parenting does not ruin kids. If it did, surely the odds are that at least one of ours would be ruined by now. Instead, I believe it strengthens and empowers kids to be their very best, because they know that there are two people 100% on their side, always, and forever. And those two people are their parents.
I know our parenting philosophy is not for everyone. There are many ways to raise children well. But for us, this was, and is, the best fit. One more thing. If you're looking for a cheap place to celebrate a birthday and one whose environment elicits great philosophical discussion, may I suggest Taco Bell!